Being a child who grew up with spankings, or what my Momma called "whoopings", I believe I have had more than enough experience to be able to call a side to the dreaded "To Spank or Not To Spank" argument. As a blogger I must inform that these views are of personal opinion and I am in no way discouraging other discipline methods. I actually encourage them. Where one method works for one child, the same method may not work for another child. By all means I do feel that all other options have to be fully exhausted before resorting to spanking. Spanking should never be the first resort. You have to explain, teach, warn and give time outs to a child first. But for some things don't work that way. So I will say: I am Pro-Spanking. I just have not seen enough research or data that tells me spanking will harm a child. A pop on the hand or two on the butt will not damage a child at all, if that's as far as your spankings go. I was spanked as a child and am doing quite fine thank-you-very-much! However,I do feel concern for other spankers who turn a small punishment into a physical beating. I honestly think this is what some parents imagine when they think of spanking and that this is why it is receiving such a bad image.
I definitely agree with your opinion. As a child, I was "whooped" as well and I am perfectly find. I strongly believe a child should be disciplined based on the type of person they are. Like you stated, what works for one child may not work for another. For example, I have a younger brother and while I received "whoopings" for misbehaving my brother was put on punishment or had things taken away from him. "WHOOPINGS" DID NOT WORK FOR HIM!!! He was the type of child to receive a whooping for talking back to elders and once the whooping was over he would do it again, but when our parents started to take his games away or didn't allow him to watch TV he QUICKLY got his act together!!! Spanking is indeed one form of discipline that can be used, but it DEFINITELY depends on the child. :)
ReplyDeleteExactly! Great point HDFS. I must say your parents did understand the differences in punishment for you guys. Some children do not respond to spanking like you said. I would have gotten my act together too if Mom took away my games! I think this is what a lot of parents need to realize. Instead of focusing on what not to do, focus on what works best with your child.
ReplyDelete